Thursday, November 30, 2017

On "The Story of Holly & Ivy": A Book Review


Title: The Story of Holly & Ivy 
Author: Rumer Godden 
Genre: Children/Adult Fiction

About the book… 
As the first line states, “This is a story about wishing.” Holly is a doll who wishes for a girl to love her and Ivy is an orphan who wishes for a grandmother for Christmas. When Ivy isn’t invited into someone’s home for Christmas, she’s put on the train to be sent to the Infant’s Home for the holidays, but she take matters into her own hands deciding Appleton is where her grandmother lives and ends up having a very special Christmas. 

This story first appeared in Ladies’ Home Journal in the 1950’s.    

What I think…
This is one of my favorite Christmas stories to revisit year after year both in re-reading the book and re-watching the cartoon based on it called The Wish that Changed Christmas.

Godden’s doll stories are among my favorite doll books because they never veer towards being too sappy or too silly. They have a very matter of fact manner about them in that the toys have feelings just as real as the people in the stories, which in the case of this book makes the two story lines flow much better. 


The parts of the story that focus on Holly and the toy shop show off Godden’s ability to create an entire world for the toys, their feelings, and their worries about what happens if they aren’t purchased. Abracadabra the stuffed owl, who thinks the toy shop belongs to him, couldn't be a more perfect villain. The portions that focus on the people in the story are also well done to the extent that you truly can feel sympathetic for them and want things to turn out well in the end. 

My particular edition has beautiful illustrations by Barbara Cooney (The collection Four Dolls, which I also love, includes this story and has illustrations by Pauline Baynes that are also pretty) that are warm and Christmas-y. 

To sum it all up… 
A heartwarming Christmas book that I love enough to read yearly and that I highly recommend to anyone looking for a good Christmas story either for themselves or children!


2 comments:

  1. I have this same edition! It’s been several years since I read it though. I’ll have to pull it out. I love Coathanger Christmas Tree by Eleanor Estes, though I don’t get around to reading it every year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hadn't heard of Coathanger Christmas Tree, but I love Estes' books, so I'll have to hunt down a copy!

      Delete

Happy to hear what you think...